← Sales & Marketing Consulting for Contractors

Your leads aren't the problem.
One stage is.

The leads are coming in — the jobs aren't. Usually the problem isn't the leads at all. It's one stage between the form and the signature.

Book the 20-Minute Gap Review → We find which stage is leaking the most booked jobs — 20 minutes, no pitch.
The honest answer

Four of the most common downstream reasons leads stop converting are slow response (you don't reach them while intent is hot), no follow-up (you quit after one or two tries), weak appointment setting (leads never become booked, shown appointments), and a sales process that doesn't close the estimates you do run — and more leads won't fix any of them. Lead quality, qualification, price, and fit matter too; the fix is to find which stage is costing you the most booked jobs, then rebuild that one first.

The leak map

Where the job leaks
before the signature.

A lead is a short window of intent. Most contractors lose the job in the gap after the inquiry — not on the marketing that created it. Five stages, and the job can leak at any one.

Revenue Leak Finder

Find the one gate costing you the most jobs.

Four numbers you already know. One read. The math is one tap down. Nothing is stored, nothing is sent.

Your month

Qualified inquiries only · not repeat customers · one opportunity is one lead, even if you run three estimates.
$
$

The read

1
Response
Speed to lead
A homeowner who filled out your form filled out a few others. Reach them in minutes, not hours — or the service call books with whoever answered first. In one MIT/InsideSales study, a 5-minute response made a lead 21× more likely to qualify than a 30-minute wait.
2
Follow-up
Persistence
One attempt rarely reaches everyone. Studies of millions of leads find it takes about six attempts to reach most who eventually convert — most contractors stop long before that.
3
The set
Booked, confirmed
Getting someone on the phone isn't the goal. If inquiries don't turn into booked, confirmed appointments, your setting process is leaking.
4
The show
They actually show
A booked appointment that no-shows is a confirmation leak. Reminders, prep, and re-confirmation decide who's actually standing in the driveway.
5
The close
Signed estimate
Set and show but don't sign? The leak is the estimate itself — how it's presented, how objections are handled, how you follow up after.

You don't fix all five. You rebuild the one costing you the most booked jobs first — and note that's not always the biggest drop-off: a moderate leak late in the funnel, where every recovered lead is nearly a sold job, can beat a big early one. Finding your binding constraint on real numbers is the 20-Minute Gap Review. Illustrative — healthy targets are benchmarks, not promises.

A lead is not
a customer yet.

It's a short window of intent — and in a high-ticket, in-home trade, that window is worth a lot. A five-figure job rides on a single sit-down, so a few points of show rate or close rate is worth more than a pile of new leads. It's also cheaper to fix, because you already paid to generate the leads you're losing. Activity is not progress.

That's why the honest first move isn't "get more leads." It's to measure the whole path — response, follow-up, set, show, close — and find the single stage where a repair adds the most booked, profitable jobs. That stage isn't always the biggest drop-off; it's the one where recovering a lead almost always means recovering a sold job.

Most contractors lose more jobs after the form is submitted than before it. The marketing did its job. The leak is downstream — and it's fixable.

Which leak is yours?
The tell for each stage.

You don't need software to spot your leak — you need to be honest about one month. Match the tell to your shop, and the fix is the stage to rebuild first.

StageThe tell — you'll recognize itThe fix
ResponseYou call new leads back in hours — or the next day.Contact every lead in minutes; automate the first touch.
Follow-upYou stop after one or two tries when they don't pick up.A multi-touch sequence over days, not a single call.
The setCalls happen, but few turn into a booked, confirmed time.Book the appointment on the first call — a real setting process.
The showAppointments get booked, then no-show.Confirm, re-confirm, and prep the homeowner before the visit.
The closeYou run estimates that don't sign.Rework the estimate, objection handling, and after-visit follow-up.

Why more leads
makes it worse.

If the leak is downstream of the lead, buying more leads pours water into a bucket with a hole in it: you pay more per booked job, and the hole gets bigger. The leads look cheap and the jobs get expensive.

Two channels can deliver leads at the same price while one closes at 30% and the other at 3%. On cost per lead they look identical; on cost per booked job, one is ten times better. Until the downstream leak is fixed, every new lead just makes the leak more expensive — which is why the cheapest-looking leads are often the most expensive jobs you can buy.

The right first question isn't "where do I get more leads?" It's "what is a booked job actually costing me, and where is it leaking?" — see cost per booked job.
A peer agency owner watched us
measure past the lead
★★★★★

“…measure marketing effectiveness beyond traffic and leads. He even took into account the crew's installation capacity. Things we never would have thought of on our own.”

Gregg Murray · Founder, Relaunch Digital Verified Google review · agency peer

Find the stage that's
leaking the most jobs.

20 minutes. We trace your leads from response to signed job and name the one to rebuild first. No pitch.
Book the 20-Minute Gap Review →

Questions about leads
that won't close

Usually because the problem is downstream of the lead, not the lead itself: slow response, no follow-up, weak appointment setting, or a sales process that doesn't close. Lead quality and fit matter too, but for most contractors the biggest recoverable losses happen between the inquiry and the signature — stages you already paid to reach.
There's no universal number — it depends on your trade, ticket, lead source, and sales process. Chasing a benchmark is the wrong move anyway. The number that matters is cost per booked job, not conversion rate in the abstract: a lower conversion rate on cheaper, higher-intent leads can beat a higher rate on expensive ones. Measure to the booked job.
Usually no. If the leak is downstream — response, follow-up, set, show, or close — more leads just raises your cost per booked job and makes the leak more expensive. Fix the leaking stage first; you're recovering jobs you already pay to generate, which is almost always the higher-return move.
Minutes, not hours. Intent decays fast, and a homeowner who filled out your form usually filled out a few others — the contractor who reaches them first, while they're still thinking about it, has the edge regardless of who has the better website. If you're responding in hours, speed to lead is very likely one of your leaks.
It can be either — and telling them apart is exactly the diagnosis. If the right people aren't finding you, that's marketing; if they arrive and leak downstream, that's the sales side. See is it a sales or marketing problem? for the five-question test that separates them.
You follow one month of leads through all five stages and watch where the most booked jobs fall out — then weigh each leak by how many sold jobs a fix would recover, not just how many leads it loses. That's what the 20-Minute Gap Review does: name the one stage to rebuild first, on your real numbers.
Andrew-Ryan Profaci, Founder of Andrew Ryan Marketing
Written by the founder
Andrew-Ryan Profaci — Founder, Andrew Ryan Marketing (Johnson City, TN). Before the agency, Andrew-Ryan ran a dealership's entire lead-to-sale engine — the phones, the follow-up, and the close — and learned to measure marketing to the booked job, not the click. He ran campaigns for enterprise appliance brands like GE, Whirlpool, and Bosch. He's been both a CMO on the inside and an outside vendor with an ops, sales, and marketing background. He sees your entire business as a system, and now he builds those same revenue systems for contractors and home-service companies.

Stop losing jobs you
already paid to reach.

Twenty minutes. We trace your leads from first response to signed job and tell you the one stage to rebuild first — before you buy another lead.

Book the 20-Minute Gap Review →
Go deeper
Is it a sales or marketing problem? Cost per booked job What to spend on contractor marketing Agency, consultant, or fractional CMO? Contractor Sales Pipeline Optimization