Opens in a new tab
←
Sales & Marketing Consulting for Contractors

How much can you afford
to pay for a booked job?

Cost per lead is the most comfortable number in contractor marketing — and one of the most misleading. Here's the number that actually tells you what works.

Book the 20-minute Gap Review
→
We connect your spend to booked jobs and show you the real number — 20 minutes, no pitch.Prefer email, phone, or text? Contact Andrew →
The formula

Cost per booked job = marketing spend for a period ÷ the number of booked, sold jobs that spend produced — not leads, not calls, not form fills. It's a marketing metric: the cost to win a job, not the cost to do one (that's job costing). Most contractors track cost per lead, which hides the truth: the cheapest leads often produce the fewest jobs. Two versions matter — a fully loaded cost per booked job (all marketing cost) tells you overall efficiency, while channel-level media spend per booked job is the fair way to compare Google vs. Meta vs. LSAs. To calculate either, you need each sold job connected back to its originating marketing source.

 

One metric, two numbers
— and you need both.

"Cost per booked job" isn't a single figure. It's two, and they answer different questions. Confusing them is how contractors cut the channel that was actually working.

Fully loaded

What a job really costs you

All marketing cost ÷ booked jobs

Every marketing dollar — media, agency fees, tools, tracking — divided by every booked job. This is your true efficiency number: what it actually costs your business to win one job, all in. Use it to judge the whole marketing operation, not to compare one channel against another (shared costs make that unfair).

Channel-level

Which channel to compare

One channel's media spend ÷ its booked jobs

A single channel's ad spend divided by the jobs that channel booked — media only, no shared overhead. This is the fair way to compare Google vs. Meta vs. LSAs, because each carries just its own cost. Use it to move budget toward what books jobs — but never mistake it for your all-in cost.

The numberFormulaWhat it tells youUse it to
Fully loadedall marketing cost ÷ booked jobsWhat a job truly costs to win, all in — media, fees, tools, time.Judge the whole marketing operation.
Channel-levelone channel's media spend ÷ its booked jobsWhat that one channel costs to book a job, media only.Compare channels fairly and move budget.

Why cost per lead
lies to you.

Cost per lead is comfortable because it's easy to get and always looks like a deal — but close rate is where the truth hides. Two channels can produce leads at the exact same price while one closes ten times better. On cost per lead they're identical. On cost per booked job, they're not close.

Channel A — "cheap" leads
Cost per lead$60
Close rate10%
Jobs per 100 leads10
Per booked job$600
Channel B — same lead price
Cost per lead$60
Close rate30%
Jobs per 100 leads30
Per booked job$200

Same lead price. One books a job for $200, the other for $600. The cheapest-looking lead is often the most expensive job — which is why you judge spend by the booked job, not the lead.

For scale: independent 2025 benchmarks put a home-services search-ad lead near $90, and over $200 for higher-ticket trades like windows and roofing (LocaliQ, 2025). What each is worth still comes down to how it closes.

The lever most contractors never price

That gap is close rate — and it's a lever you already own. Lift it ten points and every booked job gets cheaper on the same leads and the same spend. Across a year of jobs that's five figures back in margin, without buying a single extra lead. It's the cheapest growth on the page — and the one no ad platform sells you.

The calculation,
done right.

1

Pick a window

A month is usually too short for longer sales cycles; a quarter is often cleaner. Use whatever matches how long your jobs take to close, so spend and the jobs it produced line up in the same window.

2

Total the spend

For a fully loaded number, include everything — media, agency fees, tools, call tracking, the staff time that runs it. For a channel comparison, use each channel's media spend on its own, so shared costs don't distort which channel is really cheaper.

3

Count booked jobs, by source

Not leads. Sold, signed jobs, connected back to their originating marketing source. This is the step most contractors can't do — because the source data was never connected to the sale. How much credit each touch deserves is an attribution question.

4

Divide, then compare

Spend ÷ booked jobs. Now line the channels up side by side. The winner is rarely the cheapest-per-lead channel — and the one you were about to cut may be the one quietly booking the most profitable work.

A peer agency owner on measuring
what marketing really does
★★★★★

“He took the time to learn about existing bottlenecks, how to identify new growth opportunities, and measure marketing effectiveness beyond traffic and leads.”

Gregg Murray
· Founder,
Relaunch Digital
Verified Google review · agency peer

See your real cost
per booked job.

20 minutes. We find the channel quietly booking your most profitable work — and the one you should cut. No pitch.
Book the 20-minute Gap Review
→

Cost-per-booked-job
questions

How do you calculate cost per booked job?+
Divide your marketing spend for a period by the number of booked, sold jobs that spend produced — not leads. Do it two ways: fully loaded (all marketing cost ÷ booked jobs) for your true efficiency, and channel-level (one channel's media spend ÷ its booked jobs) to compare channels fairly. The hard part is counting booked jobs by source, which requires connecting each sale back to its originating marketing.
What's the difference between cost per lead and cost per booked job?+
Cost per lead is spend ÷ leads; cost per booked job is spend ÷ sold jobs. The gap between them is your close rate. Cost per lead can make a bad channel look cheap: a $60 lead that closes at 10% is a $600 job, while the same $60 lead at 30% is a $200 job. Judge by the booked job — the lead price alone can point you the wrong way.
What is a good cost per booked job for contractors?+
There's no universal number — it depends on your trade, ticket, margin, market, and season. A good cost per booked job is one that's comfortably below the profit a job earns you, and trending down as your system improves. Chasing someone else's benchmark is less useful than knowing your own number and whether it's falling. Anchor it to your average job value and margin, not an industry figure.
Should I include staff time and software in the cost?+
For the fully loaded number, yes — media, agency fees, tools, call tracking, and the staff time that runs it all. That's what tells you what a job truly costs to win. For a fair channel comparison, strip it back to each channel's own media spend, so shared overhead doesn't make one channel look artificially expensive.
Is cost per booked job the same as customer acquisition cost (CAC)?+
Essentially, for a business where a customer is one job. Cost per booked job is the contractor-friendly way to say CAC: what you spent to win one signed job. The nuance is repeat and referral work — a customer who books again, or refers a neighbor, lowers your effective cost over their lifetime. For a single-job comparison, treat them as the same number.
Why is my real cost per job higher than the lead price I was quoted?+
Because the quote was a lead price, and only a fraction of leads become jobs. A "$50 lead" that closes at 20% is a $250 job before you count agency fees, tools, and the leads that went nowhere. The advertised per-lead cost is always lower than the real per-job cost — the difference is everything that happens between the lead and the signature.
Andrew-Ryan Profaci, Founder of Andrew Ryan Marketing
Written by the founder
Andrew-Ryan Profaci
— Founder, Andrew Ryan Marketing (Johnson City, TN). Before the agency, Andrew-Ryan ran a dealership's entire lead-to-sale engine — the phones, the follow-up, and the close — and learned to measure marketing to the booked job, not the click. He ran campaigns for enterprise appliance brands like GE, Whirlpool, and Bosch. He's been both a CMO on the inside and an outside vendor with an ops, sales, and marketing background. He sees your entire business as a system, and now he builds those same revenue systems for contractors and home-service companies.

Stop funding channels
on the wrong number.

Twenty minutes. We connect your spend to booked jobs and show you the real cost per job on each channel — so you can feed what pays and cut what doesn't.

Book the 20-minute Gap Review
→